ban.do | We exist to help you be your best.

Colored Pencils: How to Choose the Right Set for Your Art

Colored Pencils: How to Choose the Right Set for Your Art

By ban.do | We exist to help you be your best. | Published: 2026-08-29

Category: Buying Guides

Discover how to pick the best colored pencils for your art style, budget, and skill level with our practical buying guide.

Colored pencils are a versatile and beloved medium for artists of all levels. Whether you're sketching, illustrating, or adding vibrant hues to your journal, the right set can make a world of difference. With so many options available, from student-grade to professional-grade, choosing the perfect set can feel overwhelming.

In this guide, we'll break down the key factors to consider when buying colored pencils, including wax vs. oil-based cores, color range, lightfastness, and budget. We'll also highlight a few standout products to help you get started on your artistic journey.

Understand the Core: Wax vs. Oil-Based

The core of a colored pencil determines its texture, blendability, and durability. Wax-based pencils are the most common and are known for their smooth application and vibrant colors. They are easy to blend but can develop a waxy bloom over time, which is a hazy film that appears on the artwork. Oil-based pencils, on the other hand, have a firmer core that resists breakage and produces less bloom. They are ideal for detailed work and layering.

For beginners, wax-based pencils are often more forgiving and affordable. If you're looking for professional results and don't mind a slightly higher price, oil-based pencils offer superior lightfastness and control. Consider your preferred technique: if you love blending and shading, wax-based might be your go-to; if you prefer crisp lines and detailed work, oil-based could be a better fit.

  • Wax-based: smooth, blendable, budget-friendly.
  • Oil-based: durable, precise, less prone to bloom.
  • Test both to see which feels comfortable in your hand.

Consider Color Range and Pigment Quality

The number of colors in a set can range from 12 to over 200. While a larger set offers more variety, it's not always necessary. Many artists work beautifully with a well-chosen set of 24 or 36 colors, especially if they learn to blend and layer. Quality matters more than quantity: look for pencils with high pigment concentration for rich, saturated colors that don't fade quickly.

When evaluating pigment quality, check for lightfastness ratings. Professional-grade pencils often have ratings from the ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) indicating how resistant they are to fading. If you plan to sell or display your art, investing in lightfast pencils is crucial. For practice and everyday use, student-grade pencils are perfectly fine and much easier on the wallet.

  • Start with a 24 or 36 color set to learn blending.
  • Check lightfastness ratings for archival quality.
  • High pigment concentration means more vibrant art.

Watercolor Pencils: A Versatile Option

Watercolor pencils are a hybrid medium that allows you to create both dry colored pencil drawings and watercolor washes. You can apply the pencil dry for fine details, then use a wet brush to dissolve the pigment and create soft, painterly effects. This versatility makes them a favorite among mixed-media artists and journalers.

If you're interested in watercolor pencils, look for sets that are labeled 'water-soluble' and test them with a brush to see how they react. They are available in both student and artist grades, and many brands offer sets that include a brush or a water pen. Remember that watercolor pencils require a bit of practice, so don't be discouraged if your first attempts don't look perfect.

  • Great for combining drawing and painting.
  • Look for 'water-soluble' on the packaging.
  • Practice with a wet brush to control pigment flow.

Budget and Brand: Finding the Right Balance

Colored pencils range from under $10 to over $100 for professional sets. As a beginner, you don't need to splurge on the most expensive brand. Many mid-range options offer excellent quality at a reasonable price. Brands like Prismacolor, Faber-Castell, and Derwent are well-regarded, but there are also great budget-friendly choices like Crayola and Arteza.

When choosing a brand, read reviews and consider the specific needs of your art. Some brands excel in softness and blendability, while others are praised for their durability and color accuracy. It's also worth checking if you can buy individual pencils to replace colors that run out quickly, which is a cost-effective strategy in the long run.

  • Start with a budget set, then upgrade as you improve.
  • Research brands for specific strengths.
  • Consider open stock for replacement pencils.

How to Test and Compare Sets

Before committing to a full set, try to test the pencils in person at an art supply store. Many stores have display sets where you can scribble on paper to feel the texture and see the color payoff. If you're shopping online, look for swatch videos or images that show the pencils in action. Pay attention to how the pencils feel in your hand: some are thicker and more comfortable for long drawing sessions, while others are slimmer and more precise.

You can also purchase a few individual pencils from different brands to compare them side by side. This hands-on approach helps you understand the differences in hardness, pigment, and blending before investing in a full set. Remember, the best colored pencils are the ones that feel right for your unique style.

  • Test in-store whenever possible.
  • Watch swatch videos online for color accuracy.
  • Buy singles to compare before purchasing a set.

Top Picks to Consider

While we don't sell colored pencils directly at ban.do, we do offer a range of art supplies that complement your coloring adventures. For instance, our Highlighter Brush Pen Set is perfect for adding vibrant accents to your illustrations, and our Airy Puffin Socks - Whisky will keep your feet cozy during long drawing sessions. These products, along with our Mini Nylon Shoulder Bag - Caper, make great companions for artists on the go.

When you're ready to purchase colored pencils, consider what you've learned here and choose a set that aligns with your artistic goals. Whether you're a hobbyist or a professional, the right tools can elevate your creativity and bring your visions to life.

  • Pair your pencils with a quality sketchbook.
  • Keep your supplies organized with a stylish bag.
  • Don't forget to protect your finished artwork.

Choosing the right colored pencils doesn't have to be complicated. By understanding the differences in core types, color quality, and budget, you can find a set that suits your needs and inspires your creativity. Remember to test and compare, and don't be afraid to start small and grow your collection over time. Happy coloring!

Shop Related Products

Small Recycled Leather Crescent Bag - Mahogany

Small Recycled Leather Crescent Bag - Mahogany

$75.00 $150.00

Shop Now
Dreams: 100 Affirmations For A Good Night's Sleep

Dreams: 100 Affirmations For A Good Night's Sleep

$7.00 $14.00

Shop Now
Small Nylon Bowler Bag - Caper

Small Nylon Bowler Bag - Caper

$23.00 $46.00

Shop Now
Color Outside the Lines Colored Pencils

Color Outside the Lines Colored Pencils

$9.48 $18.95

Shop Now